Summary
of the book entitled:
The legal Disposition of Human Organs
-
Comparative Study-
- First
edition: 1990/ Baghdad; second edition: 1992/ Jordan; third
edition: 1993/ Jordan; fourth edition: 1995/ Jordan.
- No. Of
pages: 174
- No. Of
references in Arabic, English and French languages: 89
- The book is
a collection of lectures I gave to the post graduate
“Private Law” students at Baghdad University - Faculty of
Law, during the years 1987-1990.
- The book
included an introduction on the biological developments and
modern medical acts and their effect on law, and the
necessity of organizing these works by the different
countries. The introduction also discussed the importance of
human organs transplantation, the transplantable human
organs, the research theme, the reasons for studying the
subject, the sources for getting human organs, the principle
of inviolability of human body, and the cases of violating
the principle of “the right to body integrity”. I mentioned
the opinions of jurists Esmin, Jean
Carbonnier, Stark and
Savatier.
- The
research plan included three chapters and a conclusion:
The
first chapter:
discusses the topic of human organs sale and the position of
religions towards the idea of financial dealing in the parts
of human body. In this chapter I mentioned the opinions of
jurists in this issue. Then I discussed the position in the
various laws of the Middle East and European countries
towards the idea of organs sale as regards legislation
aspect and the de facto status, I also referred to the
position of Arab, foreign, regional and international
organizations towards the phenomenon of dealing in the parts
of human body and the position of human rights organizations
on the problem of human organs selling as well as the
position of common law towards the prohibition of disposing
of one’s body.
In
the second chapter:
I discussed the topic of granting human organs as a gift or
donation. I distinguished between the contract of gratuity
and the contract of donation. Then I discussed the position
of civil jurisprudence on the voluntary giving of human
organs to be transplanted in the bodies of persons who need
them to survive. Further, I discussed the medical
responsibility in the transfer of organs in case a medical
error occurs, and the methods of compensating the damage.
In
the third chapter:
I discussed in detail the case of “the will to donate human
organs” and I differentiated between the will, the endowment
and the disposition of the corpse (body of the deceased) and
determining the moment of death. Then I discussed the death
criteria: cardiac arrest, circulatory arrest, brain-stem
death and the position of the various Arab legislation's,
French Law and American law in determining the moment of
death.
In
conclusion,
I mentioned many conclusions, ideas and solutions for the
problems experienced in this respect. I also included my
recommendations in the legal and ethical regulation of the
human organs transplantation processes.
Munther
Al-Fadhal